I’ve been a loyal Dropbox user for over 2 years, and I’ve found it invaluable for managing files between multiple users and machines. It’s been a great product – I don’t recall ever having any issues with it, everything just always seemed to work™.
I’ve always wanted a Dropbox account for personal use, however a limitation of Dropbox is that you can only have one copy running at any one time. So with my work account set up, I’ve had to make do without it. With the release of Google Drive I thought I’d test it out for my personal use to see how it faired up. At 1/4 of Dropbox’s price point I must say I was pretty intrigued to see what it had to offer.
Downloading and installing it was easy enough and the familiar Google docs interface is quite functional. I uploaded my library of pictures, but noticed that Drive doesn’t give any indication of upload status or speed – it only states that it’s syncing. Needless to say my network was hammered for a good few hours while my files were being uploaded, with Drive providing no way to cap the upload. Occasionally there was issue connecting to the server, but I don’t think it affected the sync that much. Then I found an interesting issue – midway through sync I realised I had a 40mb file uploading that I didn’t even want. I’ve got a slow upload, so thinking in Dropbox terms I’d just delete the file and the sync should stop. However Google Drive continued to sync the file even after deletion and just kept copying it back into the folder. I was forced to quit Drive, delete the file, and restart it to stop the syncing of the file. Not a great start.
When that was done I installed Drive on my Macbook. It had to download all the pictures via the internet – no lan sync (as we already knew, still a disappointment though). Then I realised I had put the Drive folder in the wrong location, but Drive doesn’t have the ability to move the folder. My only option was to deauthorise my account to change the location. So I did that and copied all the synced files across to the new location, but Drive can only be initialised in a blank folder. So I moved all the files out and created a blank folder for Drive, copied all the files back in so it wouldn’t have to download them all again, and started syncing. But instead of smartly figuring out that all the files were the same, Drive tried to re-upload all the files I copied AND download all the files off the server (creating duplicates of every file). Not impressed. Contrast this to Dropbox, which would simply do a checksum on every file to determine that the entire folder was already synced. So the syncing functionality of Drive (which is what you’re using it for, right?!) is sub-par.
This is only my first day with Drive but I felt compelled to write this article. I was ready to pay for the premium account before I’d even used it, but now I’m not convinced. I think I’ll just stick with Dropbox – it’s a much more solid product.
About